In most cases, replacing solid hardwood is unnecessary and far more expensive than restoration. Here's how to think about it: if your floors have deep scratches, worn-through finish, or water staining that has penetrated the wood, a full sand-and-refinish is the right call. If the finish is intact but dull or lightly scratched, a recoat (screen-and-recoat) restores the surface without removing wood. Replacement only makes sense if the boards are structurally damaged, severely warped, or have been sanded so many times there's no wood left to work with. For most Bay Area homeowners with solid oak, maple, or Douglas fir floors, refinishing delivers a like-new result at a fraction of replacement cost.
Read our full comparison guide →